COMPARISON
Mentionr vs ReplyGuy
This is the safety page. Reddit has told reporters it treats automated reply posting as spam and content manipulation, and journalists found most of the accounts showcased on that vendor's own site had been banned. We draft; you post.
The short version
- Pick Mentionr if you want the drafting without putting the account at risk.
- Pick ReplyGuy if you want posting automated — and read what happened to the showcased accounts first.
- Neither is right if what you actually want is monitoring without replying; take the free plan here and ignore the composer.
At a glance
| Capability | Mentionr | ReplyGuy |
|---|---|---|
| Posts autonomously | ✕ Never | ✓ By design |
| Human confirmation per reply | ✓ Always | ✕ |
| Per-account daily ceiling | 8, every tier | Sold by volume |
| Subreddit rules before posting | ✓ | ✕ |
| Removal detection and auto-pause | ✓ | ✕ |
| Monitoring, sentiment, analytics | ✓ | Limited |
Checked 2026-08-09 · sources linked per row · 404 Media on AI reply bots
Try Mentionr freeWhere ReplyGuy is the better choice
It is cheap and it automates a task plenty of people want automated. That is a real product decision and we are not going to pretend the demand does not exist. What we will say is what happens next: Reddit treats the activity as content manipulation, and the accounts are the thing that gets lost.
Moving across
There is nothing to import. Add your keywords, and use the composer with the rules panel and the ceiling in place.
What Mentionr costs
-
Pro
$29 /mo
$290/yr · $24.17/mo
- 1 project · 25 keywords
- Every 60 minutes
- 150 AI drafts/mo
- Slack, Discord, API
- 6-month history
-
Trial tier
Business
$99 /mo
$990/yr · $82.50/mo
- 5 projects · 100 keywords
- Every 15 minutes
- 1,000 AI drafts/mo
- 15 competitors
- 24-month history
-
Agency
$249 /mo
$2,490/yr · $207.50/mo
- 25 projects · 300 keywords
- Every 5 minutes
- 4,000 AI drafts/mo
- White-label reports
- Client dashboards
Questions
- Can I make Mentionr post automatically?
- No. There is no setting, no API endpoint and no roadmap item. One human confirmation per reply, from that human's own connected account.
- Why cap replies at eight a day?
- It is the top of the range at which community-reported shadowbans start. It is identical on every tier, including Enterprise, because a ceiling you can buy your way past is not a safety control.
- Is drafting itself against Reddit's rules?
- Drafting is not posting. What Reddit objects to is automated, undisclosed, at-scale posting — which is exactly the thing we refuse to build.
- What if my reply is removed?
- We tell you, and we pause posting to that subreddit until you confirm.
Try Mentionr free — no card
Fourteen days of Business, then Free if you do nothing. Nothing is deleted either way.